Lewis Hutchinson was a Scottish-born slave owner in 18th-century Jamaica, where he became known as the island’s earliest recorded serial killer. He lived at Edinburgh Castle in St Ann Parish, where he was accused of murdering travellers and other visitors, making his crimes one of the most notorious murder cases in Jamaica’s colonial history.

The Mad Doctor of Edinburgh Castle
Hutchinson was born in Scotland in 1733 and is believed to have studied medicine before leaving for Jamaica. He arrived in 1768 and acquired an estate in the Pedro district of St Ann Parish, which he named Edinburgh Castle. The two-storey structure had two circular towers with narrow openings that allowed occupants to observe the surrounding countryside.
The estate was situated along an important route connecting the northern and southern parts of Jamaica. For miles, it was reportedly the only stopping place between St Ann’s Bay and the surrounding districts. Travellers frequently stopped there to rest, unaware of the danger they faced.
His Activities
Hutchinson’s reputation as a murderer grew as travellers began disappearing along the road near his property. According to accounts given by Africans he held in slavery, he would shoot unsuspecting passers-by from his castle, take their possessions and dispose of their bodies.
He reportedly used the openings in the towers to shoot people travelling alone. On other occasions, he allegedly invited visitors into his home, entertained them and then shot them as they departed.
The victims’ bodies were reportedly disposed of in different ways. Some were thrown into a nearby sinkhole that became known as Hutchinson’s Hole or Kenky Hole. Others were allegedly placed inside the hollow trunk of a cotton tree, where vultures fed on the remains.
The number of people he killed is unknown. Later accounts have suggested that he murdered more than 40 people, although the exact figure has never been established. A search of his property reportedly uncovered dozens of watches and a large quantity of clothing, raising suspicions that he had robbed many of his victims.
The murder of John Callender
For years, rumours about Hutchinson’s activities circulated without leading to his arrest. The Africans he enslaved had little legal power to expose his crimes because Jamaica’s colonial laws generally prohibited them from testifying against white people.
Hutchinson’s crimes only came to public attention after he attacked a neighbouring planter, Dr Jonathan Hutton, leaving him with a serious head injury. Hutton reported the assault to the authorities and later travelled to England for treatment, returning with a silver plate in his head. According to historian Rebecca Tortello, a young English soldier named John Callender eventually went to Edinburgh Castle to bring Hutchinson into custody. Hutchinson shot and killed him.
A contemporary account, however, gives a different explanation for Callender’s visit. In a letter from Kingston dated April 1, 1773, published shortly after Hutchinson’s execution, Callender was described as a neighbour who had approached Hutchinson over a donkey grazing on his property. Hutchinson agreed to have the animal returned to the road but shot Callender as he turned to leave. The account also described a sick man staying at the castle who heard the gunshot and later escaped to report the killing.
Following Hutchinson’s arrest, one of the Africans he enslaved reportedly gave investigators information that helped them locate the place where he had hidden Callender’s head. Nearly 20 other human skulls were reportedly discovered at the location. Callender’s body was found separately in a deep rocky cavity and identified by his clothing.
Hutchinson was convicted of Callender’s murder and hanged in Spanish Town on March 16, 1773. At the time, Jamaica’s colonial laws prevented enslaved Africans from testifying against white defendants because they were considered inferior and their accounts were not regarded as reliable evidence

This meant that although an enslaved African reportedly helped investigators locate Callender’s remains after Hutchinson’s arrest, he could not provide admissible testimony against him at trial.
Hutchinson’s execution in 1773 brought an end to his life, but accounts of the murders at Edinburgh Castle continued to circulate long after his death. The estate eventually fell into ruins, while Hutchinson remained part of Jamaica’s history as the island’s first recorded serial killer.
More Stories of Enslavers and Their Crime
Thomas Thistlewood: The Serial Rapist Who Documented All of His Crimes Against His Slaves in a Diary
Delphine LaLaurie: The Serial Killer Who Sadistically Tortured and Killed Her Slaves for Fun
Sources:
1773: Lewis Hutchinson, “the most detestable and abandoned villain”
https://www.jnht.com/site_edinburgh_castle.php
https://old.jamaica-gleaner.com/pages/history/story0036.htm
https://slaveryandfreedomlaws.lib.unb.ca/laws/jamaica-1748

